doc:signing_comments

Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

Link to this comparison view

Both sides previous revision Previous revision
Next revision		 Previous revision
doc:signing_comments [2026/04/13 13:49] – [Using the toolbar] Simon Grantdoc:signing_comments [2026/04/13 14:19] (current) – [Signing comments] Simon Grant
Line 4: Line 4:
  
 //Try out all these techniques below in the [[playground:playground]].// //Try out all these techniques below in the [[playground:playground]].//
 +
 +----
 +
 +This is not for all edits. In any case you can see who made which edit on the "Old revisions" button, and you can see who last edited the page at the bottom right: that is put there automatically. Equally, if there is a reasonable consensus between curators, there is no point to claiming individual authorship.
 +
 +The one vital exception to this is in the "Commentary" section, which is explained along with [[templates]] for topic pages. The point here is to encourage individual curators to put their own personal perspective, in cases where their personal position is not the same as the consensus of other curators. Individual curators may also use that space to add any helpful comments, where they are not sure about the consensus and they haven't talked it over.
 +
 +In these cases, put your signature after your comment, leaving comments from individuals in separate paragraphs.
  
 ===== Using the toolbar ===== ===== Using the toolbar =====
 +
 +This is the recommended method of inserting your signature.
 In the toolbar you will see the icon {{signing-icon.png|This is an illustration; don't click here!}} which if you hover over it is called "Insert Signature". If you click on that, it will insert, at your cursor position, the code: In the toolbar you will see the icon {{signing-icon.png|This is an illustration; don't click here!}} which if you hover over it is called "Insert Signature". If you click on that, it will insert, at your cursor position, the code:
  
Line 13: Line 23:
  
 --- //[[user:asimong|Simon Grant]] 2026/04/13 13:39// --- //[[user:asimong|Simon Grant]] 2026/04/13 13:39//
- 
-It would be messy if you did this for all edits, and in any case you can see who made which edit on the "Old revisions" button. Equally, if there is a reasonable consensus between curators, there is no point to claiming individual authorship. 
- 
-The one vital exception to this is in the "Commentary" section. See the annotated [[template]] for topic pages. The point here is to encourage individual curators to put their own personal perspective, in cases where their personal position is not the same as the consensus of other curators. Individual curators may also use that space to add any helpful comments, where they are not sure about the consensus and they haven't talked it over. 
- 
-In these cases, put your signature after your comment, leaving comments from individuals in separate paragraphs. 
  
 ===== DokuWiki syntax ===== ===== DokuWiki syntax =====
  
 +This simply takes longer, so you are encouraged to use the toolbar, as above.
  
-===== Markdown syntax =====+===== MediaWiki =====
  
 +In Wikipedia and other MediaWiki installations, you can sign using `~~~~`, producing something similar to what is given above using the toolbar. This does not work here, it just gives:
  
 +~~~~
  
-===== MediaWiki ===== +So, again, you are encouraged to use the toolbar.
- +
-See [[MediaWiki and DokuWiki]]+
  • doc/signing_comments.1776088172.txt.gz
  • Last modified: 2026/04/13 13:49
  • by Simon Grant